How to Pray When God Feels Far — Augustine’s Confessions Pattern
⏱ 11 min read
You did not arrive here by accident. The phrase how to pray when God feels far is the phrase of a woman who has been keeping the practice — the morning page, the evening reading, the Sunday seat — through a stretch in which God Himself seems to have quietly moved out of the room. The chair is the same chair. The Bible is the same Bible. The scripture is being read. The prayer is being said. And the Person the chair was for is no longer audibly in it.
This is older terrain than the modern devotional shelf will admit. The early church called it abandonment. The medievals called it aridity. Augustine, who walked through one of the most documented stretches of it in the late 4th century and wrote about it with more honesty than almost any pastor since, gave the church the language it still uses. The slow practice this essay walks has its 140-day home in the Prayer Journal for Women, but the essay itself will simply read three of Augustine’s Confessions passages, slowly, and let him say what he came to say about the prayer for the long-silent God.
If you have been searching for when you feel spiritually dry — the practice for the year God goes quiet, you are in the room next door to this essay. The dryness and the distance are not the same — but they share a wall, and the women who walk one usually end up walking the other before the stretch is done.
The first thing Augustine names — the restless heart
The most-quoted line of Augustine is also the most under-read. It comes early in the Confessions, in a moment most editors place at the end of the first chapter, and it has been so frequently embroidered into homemade pillows that the modern reader has lost the texture of it. Set the embroidery aside. Hear it as Augustine wrote it — in the middle of a wakeful night in Milan, sometime around the year 397, the candle low, the room quiet, the inward face turned at last:
“Thou awakest us to delight in Thy praise; for Thou madest us for Thyself, and our heart is restless, until it repose in Thee.”
— Augustine, Confessions
Read it slowly. Do not let the familiarity of the phrase erase what Augustine is doing in it. He is not making a piece of theological poetry. He is making a diagnostic claim about the woman who is sitting in her chair tonight feeling God as far. The claim is — the felt-far-ness you are inside of is the structure of the heart itself. You were made for Him. That is why the absence is unbearable. The restlessness is the right response to the right longing. The pain is a piece of correct theology about your interior.
This is doing something most modern devotionals will not do. Most modern devotionals, faced with the woman whose God feels far, will reach for a verse that promises His nearness — He is near to the brokenhearted, He will never leave you nor forsake you, He is closer than a brother. Those verses are true. They are also, sometimes, the wrong reach for the woman in this stretch, because they suggest that the felt-distance is a measurement error to be corrected by better belief.
Augustine will not let you off the hook that fast. He says, in this single line — no, the distance you are feeling is, in some measure, the design of the longing. The heart was made for God. When the felt-presence withdraws, even for purposes you cannot read yet, the heart is going to be restless. The restlessness is not failure. The restlessness is the unmistakable signature of a soul that was made for the One who is currently quiet. You are not broken because you ache. You are made-for-Him, and the ache is the proof.
This reframes the prayer that you cannot find tonight. The prayer is not please come back so I can stop feeling restless. The prayer is — Lord, the restlessness is real, and the restlessness is, You taught me, the signature of being made for You. I am here, with the restlessness, and the restlessness is the prayer. Augustine prayed this prayer for years. It got him to the place his more famous later prayers came out of.
A small thing for the body before the next passage
Notice the chest. The chest is where the felt-far-ness sits in the body — a hollow weight just under the breastbone, the sense of a space that should be occupied and is not. Press both feet flat to the floor. Let the shoulders drop by an inch. Let one slow inhale come into that hollow space, and one slow exhale leave. The body has been holding the loneliness of God’s quietness for longer than the mind has been thinking about it. Let it set the weight down for sixty seconds. The next passage is here when you are ready.
The second thing Augustine names — the silence that is not punishment
Augustine wrote, several books later, about a long stretch in his earlier life in which God seemed to have gone silent on him. He was a young man living a divided life — half-pulled toward God, half-pulled toward the patterns of a worldly career — and in that stretch the felt-presence withdrew. He wrote about it, decades later, in a sentence the church has never quite known what to do with:
“Thou then heldest Thy peace, and I wandered further and further from Thee, into more and more fruitless seed-plots of sorrows, with a proud dejectedness, and a restless weariness.”
— Augustine, Confessions
This is the harder line. Augustine is naming, with brutal honesty, that there are stretches in the Christian life in which God holds His peace — a phrase the King James register catches well — and that during those stretches the soul does not necessarily improve. It can wander further. It can sow what Augustine calls fruitless seed-plots of sorrows. The dejectedness becomes a kind of pride — a perverse comfort in the suffering itself. The wandering compounds.
Why does Augustine name this so frankly? Because he wants the woman reading him a thousand years later to understand that the holding of His peace is not always a punitive act. God did not stop loving Augustine in his late twenties. God was, in Augustine’s mature reading, doing the slow work of letting Augustine taste the futility of life apart from felt-presence, so that when the felt-presence returned, Augustine would know — at a depth no theology lecture could reach — that the felt-presence was the substance of his life and not its decoration.
Read the line again. Thou then heldest Thy peace. God is the subject. The withholding is His. It is not your failure. It is not your sin. It is, in Augustine’s reading, a particular shape of love — the love that lets the beloved taste the absence, so that the eventual return is received with a depth of gratitude no shortcut could have produced.
This does not make the silence easier in the moment. Augustine would not pretend that it does. He wrote about that stretch as fruitless seed-plots and restless weariness, not as a peaceful spiritual exercise. He wants you to know that the stretch is hard. He also wants you to know that it is not the end of the relationship. The God who held His peace was the same God who, eventually, broke it — and who, in breaking it, taught Augustine the deeper nearness the early felt-presence had only been the introduction to.
The slow home for this kind of praying
The Prayer Journal for Women is built, day by day, for the stretch Augustine is describing. Not a journal that demands you produce a sense of nearness you do not have. A page that gives you scripture pre-printed — including, on many days, the very passages that walked Augustine through his own dry years — and a small structure for the I am still here, Lord, even in Your peace-holding prayer that this kind of stretch eventually settles into. It is built for the woman who is keeping the chair without the comfort, and who knows, at some level, that the keeping itself is the act of love the chair is for.
(If the felt-distance has bled into the kind of anxious overthinking that wakes you at three in the morning trying to solve the silence, the companion essay is prayer for anxiety and overthinking — calm your mind with scripture, and if the prayers you have been bringing to the silent God have grown small enough that you are now slightly embarrassed by them — Lord, are you even there? and the ones smaller than that — a daily prayer journal that holds the asks you’re embarrassed to pray is the practical home for that kind of asking.)
The third passage — the prayer Augustine eventually found
Augustine’s Confessions is not, in the end, a book about a silent God. It is a book about the prayer the silent God eventually drew out of him — the prayer that could only be prayed after the silent stretch, and that could not have been prayed before it. Listen to the prayer that came out of him near the end of Book IX, after the long wandering and the longer silence:
“O Lord my God, give ear unto my prayer, and let Thy mercy hearken unto my desire: because it is anxious not for myself alone, but would serve brotherly charity; and Thou seest my heart, that so it is.”
— Augustine, Confessions
Sit with this prayer for a minute. It is not the prayer of a man trying to make God speak. It is the prayer of a man who has stopped trying to control the timing of God’s voice, and who has settled, instead, into the slow asking-for-mercy that does not demand a return slot. Let Thy mercy hearken unto my desire. He is not even asking God to answer. He is asking God to hear. He has learned, through the long silence, that the hearing is the gift — and that the answering, if it comes, is the surprise on top of the gift, not the contract.
This is the prayer the long-silent God eventually draws out of you. Not the eloquent prayer. Not the desperate prayer. The simple, settled prayer that asks for hearing and not for performance — and that trusts the hearing to be enough. Thou seest my heart, that so it is. Augustine is offering God the unvarnished interior — anxious, hopeful, mixed, partial — and asking only that God see it.
The woman who learns to pray this prayer is the woman the long silence has built. She does not pray it before the silence; she cannot. The silence is the apprenticeship into this prayer. The long stretch of feeling Him as far is, in Augustine’s reading, the slow forging of a deeper way of asking — one that does not collapse when the felt-presence is absent, because the asking itself has been re-grounded in the being-seen rather than the being-felt.
This is the Confessions pattern, in one phrase — the silence forges the prayer. The prayer you cannot find tonight is being slowly built, by the very absence that is hiding it. You will pray it eventually. The silence is making the woman who can.
(The evening hours — when the felt-distance is loudest, after the children are down or the work is closed and the house has gone quiet — are the hours this prayer is most often forged in; what is evening devotion (and why it’s the quiet-time sweet spot) is the companion essay on the slot of the day Augustine wrote most of the Confessions in. He was, after all, a night-writer; the Confessions is largely an evening book.)
A second small thing for the body, before the close
Notice the jaw. The felt-distance does its quiet work in the jaw — the small set, the slight clench, the holding of the face into the I-am-still-keeping-the-practice posture even when the inward weather is collapsed. Let the jaw soften by a small amount. Not to perform peace. Just to give the face one minute of not being the carrier of the silence by itself. One slow inhale. One slow exhale. The close of the essay is here when you are ready.
What Augustine is not saying
Before this closes — Augustine is not saying every felt-distance is a meaningful divine pedagogy. Some felt-distance is medical. Some is grief. Some is the cumulative weight of a season the soul could not hold. Augustine is too good a pastor to flatten the question into a single category. He is naming a pattern, not a rule — the pattern that the long-silent stretches, in the lives of women who keep the practice through them, tend to produce a deeper and more durable prayer than the felt-presence years could have.
He is also not saying you should be glad of the silence. The Confessions is full of his honest distress at it. The honesty itself is the gift. He has given the church permission to be the woman who names the silence, who keeps the chair through it, and who asks God to hear her even when she cannot tell whether He is.
The sentence to keep near the page
Take this one with you, if you take one — Thou madest us for Thyself, and our heart is restless until it repose in Thee. Not as an embroidered pillow. As a small companion in the wakeful hour. The restlessness is the signature of the design. You are not broken because you ache. The ache is the proof that you were made for Him — and the felt-distance, however long it lasts, is happening inside a relationship that the ache itself testifies to.
☕ Get Seven Days of Stillness — free
A free gift from Hayley Louisa Mark. A short devotional companion drawn from the 140-Day series — seven passages, seven contemplative practices, sent to your inbox over the coming week.
No noise. No spam. Unsubscribe whenever you wish.
A companion for the long-silent stretch
The slow practice we just walked has its 140-day form in Prayer Journal for Women. A page each day, with scripture pre-printed, and space for the let Thy mercy hearken prayer Augustine eventually grew into — built for the woman who is keeping the chair through a stretch in which God is, for reasons she cannot read yet, holding His peace, and who knows the keeping itself is the love.
(The cluster siblings, if you are walking the three together — why doesn’t God answer some prayers? — Edwards on the affections and what to pray when you don’t know what to pray — Spurgeon’s counsel. Augustine, Edwards, Spurgeon. Three voices, one long question.)
